Author notes
This story took me an extraordinarily long time to finish. Several months, to be exact. (yeah, I know the word 'several' isn't an exact measure of time. So sue me.) (But, really. I was just kidding about suing me. I don't have enough money to afford a lawyer.)
I entered this story in a contest once... My first contest, actually.
I won't say how I did, as I don't want that to affect your review.
Yes, you must review. You took the time to read this, so a few more seconds won't kill you.
Everything in this story was carefully thought out right down to their names, and I tried my best to tie up any loose ends.
So tell me what you think!
I tried to break away from the stereotypical "Other personality is evil and wants to kill everyone" theme. Did I pull it off convincingly? Or was the theme of a personality who wants to help cheesy?
Comments
-
CHEESY VRS. REAL
Hi MAD;;
To answer your question...YES. I think you pulled it off nicely. You took a well worn story idea (crazy split personality with bad vrs. bad personalities) and you gave it a fresh twist. The personality fighting for good was portrayed nicely. He did not come across cheesy at all.
The beginning was layed out well and it set the scene for the reader quickly and clearly. As a reader I found the introduction of the Michael character was handled well and smoothly. It was clear that we were now dealing with Joe's alternate personality right from the get go.
Speaking of the intro to the Michael character you pulled off something nice with this. As writers when we want to introduce a character we go through all the thoughts of how are we going to introduce them to the reader, what to tell about them, how to describe then,Etc. With your approach, you side stepped all that because the reader already knew Joe and so the readers image of Michael was a breeze because he was just Joe. That may sound simplistic and stupid when said but in practice it worked nicely. If that was your orginial approach, then well done. If you just stumbled into it, keep it in your toolbox of tricks its useful.
You tried to cover so much new ground here with your fresh idea that I am surprised it only took you three months. Not only did you switch the motivation behind the alternate personilty, you went to directing his actions towards being good (again going against the norm for this topic) and you took this actioning to the point of exercising "directly" through the character Michael to attempt to alter outcomes (not the standard voices told me to do it of the Joe character) and you demonstrated how an unbalanced mind can take simple everyday life occurances (like getting and keeping a jo and turn them into complicated life or death decisions. I have a feeling a lot more planning and thought went into this and how to make it all come together than maybe you are admitting to or that many of your reviewers want to give you credit for.
From a readers perspective I had only one issue that I felt was sort of out of place and which kinda left me just ingoring part of the story. This was the whole mirror sequence. Up to the time Joe starts talking to Michael in the mirror I was confortable with Michael and I understood how he talked with Joe and in my mind there was no confusion between the two and who was saying what to who. Cool I am good with this. Then Michael start to talk to Joe through the mirror like some stupid Alice in Wonderland character and I am thinking is this a comedy or something. Like I was connected as a reader and enjoying the scene unfolding and then it sort of hinted at becomming unreal for me. Luckly Joe smashes the mirror and we are allowed to return from wonderland and I am once again confortable with Michael. From a writers perspective I would just write this whole approach out of the story because it detracts the reader from where I want them to be,IMHO.
A lot of creative thought and work went into coming up with this story and I would not take it so lightheartly. Its good work. Showing good new creative thought and talent regardless of what you may have heard thus far.
There are some writing procedural problems with the copy that have to be cleaned up (grammar/spelling/paragraphing/use of white space just to name a few) but nothing that a good editing job would not fix.
From a writing perspective I would have to say you have far to much Narration and not enough dialogue. Most times this would slow the story down but you have avoided this with your action/conflict keeping the story moving along. I would say that because you have such a unique character situation in the story take fuller advantage and dialogue as much of the action between the characters as you can. You can create and substain action/conflict just as well through dialogue as you can through narration but without giving the appearence of slowing the story down or making it seem to long. Although I would agree with the comment that this has the serious potential for a nice chapter story.
A fine demonstration of the creative process. Keep the juices flowing
Paul
-
Quite good
You did a very good job with this. The story was grasping. It was interesting how Micheal knew of Joe and how this wasnt a case of split personality or at least not in the usual sense of the term. Great job

-
I read this story and it was amazing! I loved all the emotions, the thought process, the character...or characters. It was wonderful
-
Decent
it was okay. i liked the idea and the plot was pretty good, but a few characters lacked feeling. the ending was a good one, for me, and all in all, the story was a good read, and the best i've read in a while. plus i love stories of paranoia.
-
A good read... really liked it. Done a great job on putting across the two characters in an uncomplicated manner.. like the mirror convo esp.
-
i love it....soooo great....*runs off to find more of ur stories.*


-
Excellente.
Wonderful
I loved it!! I loved the ending. And it's true people don't remember the nice things you do for them and likewise, it's true that people just plant these bad things in their heads and expect others to make their lives wonderful. Ha-Ha.
-
This is a great stroy. I found a few things I'll go over in a minute, but first I want to say I really enjoyed it.
Okay I'll start with the ratings and why I guess. The begging was a little forced I felt. I would have held out on letting the reader know that they where the same person. You have susspence built into this story I would make sure to use as much of it as I could.
As for the end I love the consept, the helpful split goes off the deep end. I didn't see it coming and it was very well done I think.
The characters where great, and I like the plot. But the language could use some work I think. I kept wanting more discriptions, a deeper enviorment.
As for the dialog, that was a personal perfrance. I think that some of the things they siad should have been said in there head and some things should have been said aloud. I'll go a head and read this agin and see if I can give you a more spacific examples of what I mean.
..................................
I first to start I think persent tence "It is Dark" it would help move the story, Then Like I said discription, "A man's voice," a soft/dark/black voice, "a voice echoing in the darkness.
"There was a soft click."
Discription, discrib the furniture. Cheep/ torn/ nice/ ect. Discribe the desk, large/oke?
Then to add to the story instead of "This was because....." I would put, It was michaels job to save Joes life. This leaves the reader woundering is he's joe, and angle, a city worker, or something else. I always try not to limit my options tell the end of the story.
And along that line, the next line. Michael felt Joe was about to end it all. He know it wasn't because Joe was having a bad day......
.........................
Anyways those are some starter points to get you started. Don't take my advice to heart, just some pointers I saw. I could go on but I don't want to push to much. If you like the suggestions I be happy to read agin and offer more.
GREAT STORY, I really like it.

-
Well done
I greatly enjoyed this. The character(s) were well developed. I was able to gather a message from this story, whether you intended there to be one or not. It's easier to be recognized for villany than it is to be a hero, but in the end, is the recognition worth the self detriment?
If that wasn't part of your intent I will just say I read into things too much.

-
"Why wasn't his name like "Joe 2"?
Because the names are symbolic, that's why.Did no one find it odd that the name of a character who wants a simple life had a simple name, "Joe"?
Or that his split personality, his guardian angel was named "Michael"?
Did no one find it odd that Michael enjoyed the darkness, an ultimate peace... a nirvana?
It's a symbolic story meant to make you think. If I've done that, I'm satisfied with my work. -
-
I did, I did.
I saw that and thought of both. Was going to add that to my comment but got carried away, sorry. Like I said great work.
-
-
This was really good. I love split personality stories, but I espeicialy love the twist that you have put on this story. I just wished that there was more dialogue in the story, but overall good write.
. Rewarded 4
-
Woah.
What made you decide that Joe needed to have another "person" in him. Like, why was it Michael's job to ruin his life and why wasn't his name like "Joe 2"?
I loved this story and it really made me think of the guy from Matchstick Men for some unknown reason. Like, he was always really paranoid, even if he was paranoid for a different reason.
I loved how you really brought the emotions of Joe to life. He threw the phone out the window, but the way you brought it, made him have the right reasons to do so. Otherwise it would have seemed very unrealistic.
And to end my little comment, I'll ask you a question: Who was the guy to slash his tires?. Rewarded 4
-
Wow
I love it, although it did take me a while to get into it (probably just because I'm over tired) I think it is great. The way you have made Joe and Michael communicate is amusing, especially the mirror conversation.
I can sympathise with Joe as everything does seem to go so very badly for him, one thing after another, which is very sad. You have clearly laid out why he killed himself, and having Michaels thought at the end
"Everyone remembers the day that Michael decided that Joe deserved to appreciate the darkness, too."
made it very poignant.
Although it is quite tragic, I really do like this, and will be reading it again when Im not so tired because this story is going to stay with me for a while.
thank you for entering
good luck
xxx Moonlight xxx -
This amused me in a dark, twisted sort of way. Particularly when Michael spoke to Joe from the mirror and Joe, rather than being afraid, snapped at him. I commend you for a remarkably witty and original idea for this story. My only suggestion is that, perhaps, you lengthened it...went for more detail...made it ultimately into a chapter story? Don't get me wrong, I liked it a lot, I just feel that it could be enriched by more details.
Thanks for your entry!
-crimsonshadow- -
I give it a 9.2
Haha! Good stuff...and I must say I agree with Joe. Caring is one thing, but you can only let compassion go so far. Then it is better that maybe they have a taste of what they think is better. Some lessons should be learned the hard way. It is rather unfortunate that Joe will not be able to change his life according to his mistakes. Excellent write, it is surely what I needed to step away from all the cliche crap I keep reading on this site. -
:'(
Why must you two discourage everyone from ever reading my stories?
People are going to read your comment, decide that if they comment on this that you'll bother them, too, and then overall avoid me.
You see?
You are the reason I have no real friends! Now I'm forced to go cry in a corner with spiders! -
One of your best, but also I believe this to be a grand example of the stupidity of the stupidity of your writing style.
-
hooked me in.
Well, if i MUST critique, i suppose i shall.
Firstly, i enjoyed this story, i found it different and strange, two qualities i enjoy in stories.
I was however left with a feeling like.. it wasn't the end, sorta like i dunno, the story isn't over, even though theres no where left to really go with the story. Just how it was written i suppose. *shrug*
Beside the end, i found the story well written and explained. You didn't stall along with details and such. I really liked the start, hooked me in so i'd continue.
I liked how he argued with himself, i no this isn't the mood you're setting for the story, but i found it funny.. i hav a strange sense of humour.
I felt sympathetic towards Michael, which i believe was your aim. And i think his decision just to kill himself/joe was a good one.
I think i'm critiqued-out now....
Keep Writing.
† The Lonely Girl. † -
Well, I sent you your corrections, and I said this in the email, but I'll say it here too.
Interesting story. Not something I'd normally have read, but I'm glad I did. The ending was fantastic. I feel this'd make a great movie if you expanded it, maybe put some more characters in it and such. It's very well written, the only problems I saw were a few typos and the problems in the dialogue areas. While other formats are certainly allowed, standard english calls for quotes to be ended by a comma instead of a period (though ! and ? are still allowed), and then the continued sentence should start with a lower case letter.
I can't help but wonder, where does Joe go when Micheal takes over?
(oh, and something I forgot to say in the Email... the italics were the spots that were in thought. You can differentiate them however you want, or just not differentiate them, but personally, I find things easier to read if thoughts are in italics or single quotes.)










