Hush


                                            Hush
 1

   Upon a fresh April morning, with eyes closed shut, Benjamin felt the sun before he saw it. His bedroom windows did little to curb the radiant, narrow beams of light now pouring in, creeping across the marred wooden floor and the sheets of a bed where he lay, so that the threads looked dyed in rich yellow. The sounds of wildlife ensuing coaxed his attention toward the outside view, the rugged northern landscape, the swell of dense clouds floating leisurely across the muted blue of day.2

   From downstairs, he could hear, and almost picture, his mother bustling about the kitchen, spooning pancake batter with one hand and wiping her brow with the other, grey-streaked hair disarrayed as if performing such a laborious task. When she called, "Benny, your plate is ready," he groaned, wishing she would just go home and leave him to his thoughts. He was not a little child anymore, but an adult, and didn't need her to bring him out of his depression. He'd come out of it when he was good and ready. Today, he'd just lay idly.3

   Bare-chested, flat on his back, the thickly bearded man let his gaze drift to the ceiling above, where a brown spot nestled in the very center caused by a busted water pipe, which hadn't been there a few weeks ago. Just like the water stain before him, a sore rested on his soul. Last night had been an unbearable one for him. He'd dreamed of his deceased wife and child again, or had he? Between half-parted lids, he'd seen her standing under the door frame to his bedroom holding their baby boy, Benjamin Jr. on her right hip, dressed in the white cotton nightgown she died in. That midnight encounter appeared tangible, although ineffective to all but one of his five senses. Sight.4

   Benjamin recalled the apparition vividly in his mind as fruitless tears welled his eyes; she was there. Definitely there. And little Ben was there, too. Of course they were. Weren't they? Or had he simply succumbed to insanity, the side-effect of overwhelming loneliness and grief? Even so, he'd found himself sitting upright in the dark that night, between sleep and consciousness, an arm outstretched toward who he assumed were them, muttering pitifully, "Please, come back to me." 5

*** 6


                                                 Eleanor7

   I wouldn't exactly call myself a ghost. Neither my child, for that matter. I don't like the term, being that most generally associate it with the unwanted dead or paranormal doppelganger come to wreak havoc on all living counterparts. I am simply a spirit. A soul.8

   There will be no haunting. I am not here to provoke. I am simply here because I've never left. Never crossed the threshhold to the other realm calling me and my child the day we died in the fire. I hadn't wanted to go, couldn't bear leaving my beloved Ben behind. Two months of separation, and still, I can not let him go. He sees us, I know he does. I'm sure he feels he's gone crazy, and I want so desperately to tell him he's not. Just the other night, I visited him. Little Ben was eager, and so was I. Probably more so.9

   At first sight, I couldn't believe he was the same man. Sallow was his complexion, red his beard, brown his hair, wild and long and unkempt.Those cornflower blue eyes I once could stare into for hours seemed removed from expression. But why, Ben? Why pain me with your obvious misery? I wanted to enter where you slept, to hug you when you recognized my presence, and you had, but the way you looked at me that night, I knew things could never be the way they'd once been. Little Benjamin pointed to you, and I don't think you noticed. The fire took us from you, the smoke inhalation cemented our fate. But your mother, she stoked the flames.10

***
                                               
11

                                                  Benjamin12

   Mother's visiting more frequently now. Her quick, purposeful moves alerted me that she was in the house, and that sent a nervous rolling in my belly. It was her movements that'd woke me, brought me back to the inevitable pain I was sure to feel with the upcoming day. She never did know how to back off. Couldn't let me learn to breathe on my own.13

   With a jolt, I reluctantly peeled myself from bed, snapping the covers back briskly. However, I was not of a brisk mood, whereas my mother, she seemed to be enjoying my down spirits, stopping by my small house in the woods almost everyday, whistling as she prepared to do my weeks old dirty laundry, to cook my super, to press my slacks. "You need to come with me to town," she'd say, "Find some lovely woman to look after you". She never did like Eleanor, couldn't stand her, in fact. But I paid her no mind, after all, she loved looking after me. That was certain.14

   The sound of my bare feet descending the stairs faltered as I thought I heard something. A cry in the background. No, not so far away. Snapping my head back, I looked to where I had just come; at the top of the stairwell, something flashed before my eyes. A faint, disfigured blur of color. I blinked away the mirage. Then, the cry again. A baby's wail. "Little Ben," I heard myself saying before I could stifle the words. Two steps at a time, I entered the hallway, head spinning frantically about, surveying my surroundings. What exactly did I hope to find?15

   Nothing. Nothing but the sunshine sifting through the hallway window, faint speckles of dust swimming in the light like microscopic beings. "Hush," I heard her say, that sweet, distant voice.
16

   "Eleanor!" I screamed, eyes widening in disbelief. "Eleanor Mae, Benjamin Jr!" Tremulous hands before me that must have been mine, pushed doors to vacant rooms open, searching the places that were necessary where they could be, lifting the bedspread to look under the bed, checking closets, scanning the bathroom. Perhaps, these places weren't necessary at all. Under the bed?17

   A laugh, an endearing, lighthearted laugh from my Eleanor. "Eleanor, my love!" My eyes were wild, my brow with sweat, my heart aflutter.18

   "Puh-puh" came the slow whimper from the only door I had left to undertake.
19

   "My son!" I bellowed enthusiastically. I pushed open the abandoned nursery and he was there. In his crib, Eleanor by his side, whispering soothing sentiments to calm him. She smiled, and the tears came again, as they so often had since the months she'd passed away. Hesitation aside, I advanced toward them, but as I did this, they vanished. My footsteps ceased, as bewilderment invaded my features. No sooner had they appeared, now they were no more.20

   Mother came up behind me, grabbing my shoulders, ushering a dazed me out of the nursery. The door closed, and she silently led me to breakfast, not mentioning what I know she'd just witnessed, nor bringing up my peculiar behaviour. Quietly, wordlessly, I seated myself at the breakfast table, eyes downcast. Not ashamed, disappointed. A plate stacked with fluffy pancakes came into view. I couldn't eat, but while Mother stood over-top me, a determined hand pressed to my shoulder, I unwillingly brought a morsel to my mouth and half-heartedly chewed. Whatever it took to get mother away.21

   "And some freshly squeezed orange juice, you need that," she insisted, pouring my glass with the thick, pulpy substance. Obediently, I gulped that down.22

   "Bacon, too." A frying pan in her hand, she pushed a load of bacon onto my plate with the spatula, errant grease dropping on my pancakes. I stared up at her menacingly, took a bite, then let the remnants fall to my plate.23

   "Satisfied?" I grumbled.24

   "Those pancakes look dry, how about more maple syrup." And when she'd begun to douse my plate, I snatched the syrup out of her hand, and with force and anger, hurled it at the wall, the contents spattering everywhere.
25

   "Enough, Mother. Enough!" I harshly demanded, excusing myself from the table and exiting onto the porch outside. She called, but I warned her, "Not now. Leave me be."26

   Despite my words, several minutes later she met me on the porch, handed me a cigarette already lighted, which I was admittedly grateful for, and stalked over to the truck parked by an overgrown thicket that surrounded the crumbling house, pulled her keys out, then turned around, a worried look creasing her aging features, and said, "Going into town. Should be back within an hour or two. Want anything?"27

   Of course I wanted something. But the something I wanted, Mother couldn't give. "No," I tersely responded. As the faded pickup truck left the deep woods, I collapsed in one of the rockers, dragging nervously from my cigarette. The day was beautiful, the trees whispering in the slight breeze. People died every day. Life went on, why couldn't I?
28

   The steady chirping of the surrounding forest was deafening. Yet it was imperative I escape the house that had kept me its prisoner of grief for so long, so I headed for the woods, pushing through the thick undergrowth, bush and bramble, feeling the flying insects peck at my beard, the dark wet soil clinging soothingly to my feet. The creek lay in front of me, shimmering in the sunlight dappled by cascading trees. I took yet another inhale of the cigarette, exhaled a plume of smoke. 29

   "Drop that cancer stick, Benjamin Earl McAdams!"30

   She materialized before me, standing by the creek in her cotton nightgown, dark hair splayed over her petite shoulders, a ludic smile on her face. Little Ben appeared moments later, a stick in his small hand, tracing lines in the mud.31

   "Eleanor," I whispered faintly. Was I dreaming again? Had I gone crazy or was she actually there? "Baby?" I called hopefully. She waded in the creek, pulling the hem of her nightgown up as she did so. My child laughed then, clawing at the fresh air with his little fingers, summoning me to join them. Yielding, I discarded the cigarette in the wet mud, and met them near the water's surface. Yes, I stripped down to my underclothes and merrily joined them.32

***
                                                
33

                                                    Mother34

   I don't know what's gotten into him. He talks in his sleep, he drifts through the day, speaking to himself, saying, Eleanor! Eleanor! Even in death, the bitch has a hold on him. She was always the clingy type, taking my boy away from me, trying to push me to the side, to make me go away. She trapped him with that damn baby of hers. Didn't even resemble him! No McAdams produces dark haired babies! For all I know, she was a slut and could've cheated on him. I warned her. I told her to step off and let me be the mother, let me at least have that, if nothing else.35

   As I head back out of town to Benjamin, my clutch on the steering wheel tightens in anger, reflecting back on the disease that stained our life. Her. I pick up speed, my arthritic lower limbs not preventing me from exerting frustration against the pedal. In the passenger seat, there is a plastic bag containing a case of beer and a pack of cheese crackers, Benny's favorite snack. He'll love me more for it, the little things. Now we're finally getting back on track, slowly but surely. I'm relieved they're gone, the fire was right to take them. She especially had it coming. There is no regret, my hands are washed clean. I, Marylin McAdams, am a proud mother. And a proud mother always does what's best for her children, even if it means ending another's life.36

***

   Benjamin emerged from the fringes of the dense brush soaking wet, in nothing but his white boxer briefs, which had clung to him, revealing his intimate parts. He met the road out of the forest, staring disoriented into space, hands searching for something, anything to hold. His mother, edging along the road aligned with tall trees dipping overhead spotted him immediately, rooted to the middle of the road. Shocked, she stepped on the brakes and exited the cab so swiftly, running toward him, it seemed she was an agile woman in her twenties.37

   "Benny! Is that you?" she exclaimed, progressing forward, frowning disbelievingly at the spectacle. Benjamin whipped around from side to side repeatedly, wet strands of dark hair flinging wildly as he did. He didn't acknowledge her.38

   "Eleanor!" he screamed, his eyes wildly shifting back and forth, wet hair clumped awkwardly to his scalp. "Don't leave me, please! Benjamin Jr! Where are you now?"39

   Realizing the cause of his madness, Marilyn grabbed her son fiercely and slapped him hard across his face. Benjamin settled, staring at her as if she were the one who was crazy. It took him a moment to realize who this woman was. "Mama," he started, "They've left me again...not coming back, are they? Can I have them, still?" His words were unsteady, his tone grim. 40

   Placing both hands firmly against the sides of his face, Marilyn uttered, "Son, now listen. You've gone mad, and I can't bear to see you acting like this--Like a fool. They're dead. Dead. It's time to forget them, to move on....for good. They're gone."41

   He grabbed at his mother's wrists and pushed her away. "No. They're not gone! They were just here. At the creek. I was with them." He shook a finger at her, as if to tell her off. The old woman stood her ground.42

   "They're dead," she repeated softly.43

   Benjamin remained still, limp arms hanging awkwardly at his sides, his face working to quell the emotions bubbling to the surface. "Dead," he echoed. A slight, hysterical laugh came after that. "Of course. Of course they're dead." He shook his head as if to shake off the confusion. The confusion left, but a dreadful pain replaced that. Soon, he found himself sobbing, bringing his palms to his face in complete despair. The despondent sounds emanating from him prompted Marilyn to take him in her arms.44

   "Now, now," she uttered, fervor filling her eyes and tone, "It'll be fine. Everything will be as it was, you'll see. Hush now, my dear."45

   And like once before, Mother led Son out of his disgruntled stupor, toward the humming truck awaiting them. Once inside, she initiated the drive, and the truck slowly started up the road. Benjamin sat in the passenger seat, absentmindedly pushing cheese crackers into his mouth, interluding every now and then with a gulp of his beer, while simultaneously staring out the window at the swooshing forest passing by. As for his mother, she smiled to herself, going over private thoughts of what to serve for supper, but most importantly, satisfied that Benjamin, finally, was all hers again.
46

 47

Author notes

This was supposed to be written with eeriness and a sort of haunting quality, but it didn't actually come out that way. Oh well...at least I tried something different. I'm not good at creating a haunting atmosphere. I tried to use different perspectives throughout the story, so you can get a taste of each character's feelings. 

If you don't understand the story, it's about dark family secrets, a mother's dominance over her grown son, jealousy....so on. Benjamin's happiness is ruined by his demented mother's actions; she killed his family, although the details are not specific in the story, by fire. But this was no accident, she made it seem that way though.

By the way, critiques and opinions are welcome. Please point out the mistakes.

(Fav movie is Atonement)

A contest entry

Honestly, what do you think?

    : , Your review:

    Comment Suggestion: What is your your first impression?
    : Cost: 0 free left 0 points, You have 0. (?) (Line numbers)
    Ratings:

Comments

1 - 54 of 54
  • This was a touching moving story! Great job! I loved it!!


  • Pretty-Wicked
    October 3
    Edit | Reply
    Oops. Your story is 2400 - the limit was 2k.


  • lavanya
    October 2

    Edit | Reply
    wonderful story,
    i simply love the way you changing POV of different people, i mean for many people it is difficult task but u handdleedit nicely...story line is really intresting and right now i m feeling hate for mother....simply brillent work..well done and keep writing...


  • AthenazeBeauty
    September 30

    Edit | Reply
    Wow. This was haunting and beautiful. And the part where he was chasing after the voices in his house I actually got goosebumps. I found only one spelling mistake in paragraph 14. I think you were saying "to cook my SUPPER" you accidentally wrote super. I loved it. Excellent, good luck.


  • Shadow Pixie
    September 18

    Edit | Reply
    Wow! This was really creepy. I loved it - I didn't find any mistakes. You're an amazing writer. I found the idea of the mother killing her grandson and daughter-in-law incredibly eerie. It scared me!
    Thanks for your entry!

    ~ Lí-Lí


  • BlackTide
    September 9
    Edit | Reply
    since you were a finalist I chose a random section (paragraph 16) and read it, I rated it 7 (with 10 as the best) but good job!


  • seasonsoflove
    September 8
    Edit | Reply
    Good work here!!

    Plot: 4
    Language: 3
    Theme: 3

    Total: 10

    Love the point of views in this. Good job!


  • BlackTide
    September 8
    Edit | Reply
    interesting hook... maybe a finalist... good luck.


  • Bloody-Ink gold member
    August 27

    Edit | Reply

    W-O-W

    I think that about covers it....wow. You write with such feeling, such emotion that its as if I were really there. Your descriptions, as I mentioned in my previous comment, are absolutely amazing. Since I have finally gotten around to reading the whole thing (my internet is down at my house, preventing me from doing so earlier) I have dutifully kept my word to finish my comment.

    Though I loved it, very much in fact, and found few—if any—mistakes, I do have a few things to suggest. For one, I would've liked it if you did describe Elenor and Benjamin Jr. in more detail. You did describe her, yes, but I would've loved you to have described her personality and things such as that. Also, I thought it was a bit odd that it was split into so many different P.O.V's. I understand your purpous behind them, but I thought it was confusing. At least you let the reader know which P.O.V it was—I have read a few that just switch without so much as a hint of doing so.

    Anyway, in summary, I loved this. So much. I liked how you portrayed Marylin seeming to have a seething hatred for the woman her son married. Even enough so to kill her in order to have her son back to herself. I thought that was a nice twist.

    Thanks for entering, and good luck!

    Bloody-Ink

    beginning: 5, language: 5, plot: 5, ending: 5, dialog: 5, characters: 5.

  • Bloody-Ink gold member
    August 25
    Edit | Reply
    Okay, I haven't finished reading the whole thing, but I will later and as far as I can tell this is the best I've read so far. Your descriptions are amazing [for all others who read this comment, this is what I'm talking about when I say 'descriptions'. I love it so far, and I'll finish commenting once I've read it through.

  • Make Me Cry (Contest Comment)

    Notes:
    "From downstairs, he could hear, and almost picture, his mother bustling about the kitchen, spooning pancake batter with one hand and wiping her brow with the other, grey-streaked hair disarrayed as if performing such a laborious task." -- I think you could take the comma after "downstairs" out, and at "performing such a laborious task" maybe say, "performing an incredibly laborious task," or even just taking the "such" out.

    "Bare-chested, flat on his back" -- replace the comma with an "and"

    "where a brown spot nestled in the very center caused by a busted water pipe, which hadn't been there a few weeks ago." -- The clause is unnecessarily placed; you can combine this into "where a brown spot that hadn't been there a few weeks ago" to reduce the number of commas and clauses.

    "Mother's visiting more frequently now." -- that's in present tense, while the rest of Benjamin's section is in past. Was it intended to be that way?

    "It was her movements that'd woke me, brought me..." -- it should either be "that woke" or "that'd wake me, bring me."

    "To cook my super" -- "supper"

    she'd say, "Find some -- I think "find" should be lowercase, unless you change the comma after "say" into a period.

    "look after you". -- the period should be inside the quotation

    "But I paid her no mind, after all..." -- the comma should be a semicolon

    Paragraph 27 is one really long sentence; I think you can separate it into 2-3 instead.

    "Life went on, why couldn't I?" -- try "so why couldn't I?"

    "The steady chirping of the surrounding forest was deafening. Yet..." -- "deafening, yet" instead

    "...prisoner of grief for so long, so I headed..." -- I think you could stop the sentence at "long" and take out the second "so"

    "I took yet another inhale of the cigarette, exhaled a plume of smoke." -- maybe "exhaling"

    I love the word "ludic"

    "There is no regret, my hands are washed clean." -- the comma should be a semicolon

    I love how you changed POV's throughout this; it gave the reader a more in-depth and unbiased look at what really happened. The way you write is beautiful, full of imagery and flowing language.

    Marylin's a witch-with-a-B, if you don't mind me saying the plot was incredibly engaging, the characterization was good; a wonderful story. I teared up, which is definitely a good thing Good luck!

  • I really enjoy reading stories from more than one persons POV and this was very well written. To me, it was a realistic account of how someone could well feel after losing their family or loved ones. It was sad and I really felt for him. His mother seemed like a nasty piece of work. I would actually quite like to read more of this, perhaps one day you will expand it even longer. It flowed very well, it was easy to understand, it stirred emotions in me and had a lot of emotion. Keep up the good work and thank you for entering it into my contest


  • Dr. Psycho silver member
    August 12

    Edit | Reply
    I really liked the characterization used in this piece. The descriptions of the mother was really great, especially her dementia. I also liked how the reader could feel the emotions that Ben felt.

    Great Job! and thanks for entering

    beginning: 3, language: 5, plot: 5, ending: 4, dialog: 5, characters: 5.


  • silkcatseye
    August 3

    Edit | Reply
    Wow what a story, you aimed to create a haunting quality well, you succeeded. It is full of emotion, you could feel Benjamins pain and sorrow, you can feel the hatred by the mother. They were very realistic and well rounded out.
    The beginning was fast paced and flowed beautifully, I liked the way you introduced your characters and how they interacted with each other.
    The plot is well written and holds your attention as I've already mentioned your story is full of memtion.
    The language flows it is easy to read but a suggestion where you have said
    (I can not let him go)
    Cannot is one word.)
    The ending you have left open enough to add more to the story if you want to.
    A well written story.
    Good luck in the contest

    beginning: 5, language: 5, plot: 5, ending: 5, dialog: 5, characters: 5.


  • sabb.writer
    August 3

    Edit | Reply
    Oh that was so sad. Seriously I almost cried. So great though, amazing job. Oh, and you did create a some what eriee atmosphere. Amazing!


  • Juniper Cran
    July 28

    Edit | Reply
    Very well done.
    I like the mood that you started out with and the mood you ended with. Very haunting yet unique in the way it was written. I admire the transition of characters and how many damn trophies you won.
    Good job, friend


  • Onomarith
    July 28
    Edit | Reply

    Awwwww

    a very impressive play of words and emotions!!!

  • nice, it was really well written :

  • BexySitch
    July 27
    Edit | Reply
    Hush, the atmosphere you have created is very haunting, the setting is very well written and the way eleanors letter explains everything shows you have extreme talent in writing, and getting things across how they're supposed to be while keeping the gripping story intact. absolutely fantastic! the trophies you have won, and more to come i'm sure, are truely deserved.
    Thankyou for an outstanding read
    Kurtis

  • I am.
    July 19

    Edit | Reply
    This is such a sad story. The readers can sense the Benjamins grief, and the mothers frustration. It's abit chilling, and your story was able to keep my intereted and captivated!

  • That was really good=] I'm trying to give positive critism in this contest so I'll tell you that I'm picky with suspense and I thought this story could have been a little more suspensful, but I'm really picky with suspense soooooo, yea=] also ur story was a little over the word limit with 2400 words but I could let it slide=] other than that I really enjoyed the story, and I loved how the mom was the one who killed Elanor and benjamin Jr. ! well done and thank u for entering my contestt=]


  • Reaver Greeters member
    July 8

    Edit | Reply
    I will gladly read your story at another time, however for my contest, it was to be under 2000 words. I have to remove the entry.

    Sorry!
    Rian


  • Intoxica
    July 6

    Edit | Reply
    Paragraph 23, I think...the one starting with "Despite my words," was one very long sentence.
    Perhaps your only questionable decision in this story was making that paragraph so busy. If you can't say it in a breath or two, don't write it that way.
    It was very well written, in other repsects.
    Such descriptions can make "The Iron Curtain Over America" interesting...


  • toolenduso
    July 5

    Edit | Reply
    It is pretty chilling at times, even if the overall atmosphere doesn't feel like it. You've done a great job at making a crazy situation though. I think your strong suits in this story were definitely characterization and dialogue--excellent job in both those areas.

    So thanks for entering, and good luck in the contest!

    Style: 10/10
    Flow: 10/10
    Uniqueness: 5/5
    Readability: 7/7
    Effect: 9/10
    Lack of Errors: 3/3
    Personal Score: 4/5
    Total: 48/50


  • demonkitty
    June 26
    Edit | Reply
    Ouu cold! I like it~!!! Thanks for entering my contest!! Your one of the finalists!!

  • This was an interesting tale. I do have to say though that the different perspectives were a bit unnerving. Other than that, it was creative and well-written as far as I'm concerned. Thanks for entering.


  • Asfand
    June 24

    Edit | Reply
    This was wonderful! I absolutely loved it! The mother's characterization, the haunting quality of Eleanor's images, the grief-ridden man! Everything came really together to make this whole. I liked the ending. Unlike most, it was satisfying.

    Great job, thanks for entering and good luck!

  • Its good. Very nice. I would write a better comment, but I am so dang tired. Sorry about that.

    -Vio


  • LilyFate
    June 20

    Edit | Reply

    I loved it!

    Well Chickey i must say i love this story. I have read it before long ago but yet again it pulled me in and i had to reread it.


    Its creepy yet not to creepy. Hmmmmm its kinda hard to explain. :/

    And it seems like it could be real. A crazy old mother and her love of her son and hate for her daughter in-law.

    well good luck in my contest

    -LilyFate


  • Jennywinnie
    June 20

    Edit | Reply
    I really love this as I get further into the story...describing his greif...and that comes across as just describe how he remember things like...dressed in the white cotton night gown she died in...it's really good.

    I like how you put Elanor's thoughts in itallics, it kind of sets her appart...other worldly...great!

    they died in a fire? Maybe you could discuss this earlier...like he's trying not to think about how much they suffered...something like that.

    I loved...I'm simply here because I never left...that's just cool!

    i like this side of it...seeing how the deceased can suffer because their loved ones are suffering

    So does that mean that his mother killed them....I'm hooked...

    The part where he's looking for Elanor reminds me of adgar Allan Poe, Quothe the Raven nevermore

    Wow, this mom is really demented...your awesome

    I think the main thing is work with the beginning...like those first few paragraphs because they don't reflect to the reader that this is the AWESOME story that it is.

    i don't really how to do that...certainly talk about the pain he feels about the deaths sooner...or even start in the dream...those are just some thoughts.

  • Jennywinnie
    June 20
    Edit | Reply
    I love you detailed description. Especially of the mother in the beginning.

    you might mention somehow, the death of his wife and child sooner, because at first "due to the name Benny" I was thinking a three year old or something.

    But I love how you describe things, very unique, and detailed. Great job


  • Sans Titre
    June 20
    Edit | Reply
    Applause much deserved


  • Sans Titre
    June 20
    Edit | Reply

    Really, really good

    U make me wish I could write properly.....very well done...


  • ley527
    May 31
    Edit | Reply
    this didnt really keep my attention

  • Woah

    You kept me hooked till the very end!

    I thought it was eerie in a way, how a mother could be so possessive of her son that she'd get THAT jealous of her daughter-in-law. So jealous that she'd kill her and a baby in a fire. That would have been a painful way to die. Unimaginably painful.

    I also felt so bad for Benjamin, constantly seeing the ghosts of the two and then in the end, basically being under his mothers control like a kid.

  • Original and Creative

    I really liked how you could hear the thoughts of other characters, the way you put the words down itself made an atmosphere of lonleyness and longing to be with a loved one. I never expected the mother to do that, but then it started making sense, the evilness of the mother was original and creative, I enjoyed that.


  • whoudini
    May 26
    Edit | Reply

    Very good story

    and yes you are the real thing , a very good writer indeed

  • Very well written and different.
    The prompt was not in the AN or messages/commented to me...so I will need you to let me know before the contest closes or I will have to DQ you.
    This would be a real shame as I really love this piece!
    Thanks for entering my contest and good luck. :]

  • Woah! I was really surprised by the way this all turned out. It was actually a lot more realistic than I would have expected for a horror-like story like this. I love the twisted ending, though it made me a little sad inside that he lost his whole family. Though I hated his mother for killing the son, too. Oh, well... come what may, huh?

    This was a great read. Thanks for entering!


  • Other Side
    May 19
    Edit | Reply
    Hey, um thanks. I really like it. You are a really good writer.


  • MJs-Angel
    May 16
    Edit | Reply
    Hey. This is a first impression, but this story sounds really good. After I finish leaving my first impressions, I'm going to read it. I love the description you have and the beautiful wording!

    wishing-star123


  • Oleander
    May 11

    Edit | Reply
    Amazingly well done. I could feel the eeriness, but I would say the quality is most profound. I understood it too, was not too confusing. Great work here!

  • I rather enjoyed this, the tone, the presentation, all of it. Your characters are vivid and everything is well put together. Wonderful job!

  • Okay... I definitely cried when i read this( although listening to the beatles did contribute a bit) I loved this story, I think you might actually make me go into an early mid-life crisis!

    Thanks for antering and good luck! >smiles<

    -Carina

  • It was a pretty good story, but I was a little bit confused at some parts. Good luck in the contest, though.


  • Bella Corday
    April 16

    Edit | Reply
    Twisted! The mother reminded me of Norma Bates. Obsessive much? lol I like the characters, they are very realistic, even the motivations of the ghosts to stay. The mother I did not like at all, but that was more because of her persona, she is very well written. A very entertaining and engrossing read.


  • Tricia3 gold member
    April 8

    Edit | Reply

    A very good story

    Your writing is very good and the story easy to understand.
    The mother was hard to take, but all too real.
    Great story,
    Thanks for entering


  • Hinata-is-me silver member
    April 5
    Edit | Reply
    too good! i absobloodylutely loved it. haunting.


  • Fallen Star
    April 4

    Edit | Reply
    Amazing!
    As usual, of course.
    I loved hearing from the perspective of the Eleanor, and Marilyn. She was a little freaky about her son, which I thought added to it. And the eeriness I think you did pull off wonderfully, especially at the end. That final sentence took it all.
    Oh, I also did LOVE how both mother and deceased wife said, "Hush".
    Keep up the excellent work!


  • artaq gold member
    April 4

    Edit | Reply
    The Ghosts may not have been haunting but the mother sure was... Lovely and descriptive job..

    beginning: 5, language: 5, plot: 5, ending: 4, dialog: 5, characters: 5.

  • Ooh, that was sinister I liked it a lot actually, but I am very cross with Benjamins mothers, she needs a good slap or something else unpleasant! And the poor Eleanore and her son, I liked the way you included a couple of paragraphs from her, to me it felt like those paragraphs put the reader on her side. Well done for including the element of the supernatural, that's alays a plus. Thanks for entering and good luck in my contest.
    Neo


  • Rorshach gold member
    April 3
    Edit | Reply

    Like a cricket bat

    First paragraph. Stiff and dull.
    Come on, give the reader a chance.
    PLEASE GIVE ME A LIFE

  • Lissibith
    April 3

    Edit | Reply
    I think you've definitely got a bit of the haunting atmosphere going here. I really liked it, and to me, it felt like he was a lost soul from the beginning - Whatever his distaste for his mother insinuating herself back into his daily life, he wasn't saying anything to her, so in a sense, it already felt like she'd won. That feeling of hopelessness was used well.

    A few nitpicks: in paragraph 9, I think you want "bear" (endure) instead of "bare" (naked).

    There were a couple places where it felt a little like a section hadn't gotten completely into the character of the speaker. For instance, in the beginning of paragraph 15, he says "the sound of my bare feet descending the stairs faltered." But as it's him, it seems like he'd be more aware of his movement on the stairs than his footsteps - that phrasing sort of sounds like it would belong to someone in another room listening. But I think that's very much YMMV. It just threw me personally.

    I think the mother's section might have been even stronger without the last sentence cementing what you alluded to well in the rest of that part. But with or without, I loved the voice you put her in. It was chilling.

    Your descriptions are absolutely amazing, by the way. the sunlight in graph 16, Eleanore's description in 31... you really have a way of making the pictures very real.

    beginning: 5, language: 4, plot: 4, ending: 5, dialog: 5, characters: 4.


  • Rune Morose
    April 1

    Edit | Reply
    You've already got a wonderful story here, and I think I may be able to help you with the haunting atmosphere. You've already got the beginnings of loneliness and a "claustrophobic" mood going on, so if you can play that up I think you'll have it. One of the problems, unfortunately, was your "something different."

    To crank up the loneliness, you need one and only one perspective, and I vote for Ben first, the omniscient narrator second, or if you must, the mother. Don't make it seem like they are the only two people in the area, make it seem like they're the only two people in the WORLD. Try stagnating their surroundings, make the forest around them devoid of life and motion. Use clouds to block out the sun, dry up the creek, make it winter and the trees will be bare.

    The chief element that really removes the ghosts from power is having Eleanor's perspective. The ghosts should linger on the periphery of the senses. They should remain impossible to nail down, without form, through as much of the story as possible. You did very well in the scene with the stairs, letting only fragments of their voices slip through until that final vision of Eleanor beside the cradle.

    On the flipside, I think really making the creek into a beautiful place would be a good idea. Use light and life here to indicate all that his deceased family means to him, that without them, his life is dull and gray. Association is one of the writer's most powerful tools. Joyce's "The Dead" comes to mind.

    Finally, I think you shouldn't reveal the mother's role in the fire outright. Villains don't think about their villainy all the time if they think what they're doing is right. Play down her lingering vindictiveness a tad. What you have done is already quite subtle, but it could be even moreso...wait until the very end, when I noticed you compared this incident of her helping him into the truck to the night of the fire. Place something suggestive or indicative in her truck, like a gas can, or the smell of gas or ashes, and make the reader really notice it.

    I hope I've offered some helpful advice and haven't been too harsh, because I think you've already got something terrific and evocative here. It was a joy to read, and it made me write a big long comment on a night when I didn't feel like doing so when I started reading.

    Keep writing, and thanks for letting me read.


    Other comments:

    awoken?

    "exhaled out" is redundant

1 - 54 of 54