The Essay Essay

The Essay Essay1


2

I bit down hard on my pen, a habit I usually don't show unless incredibly pressed for ideas or time. The previous three—or five—drafts weren't good enough. “What do I do now?” I asked myself. I screamed in frustration. I wouldn't dare turn in an essay in its first draft solely because I didn't know how to fix it. I thought hard.3

It was February 7, 2008, around one o'clock. It was an unusually warm day, and I was in a good mood because of the sudden change in weather. The professor had given us the prompt, had us formulate ideas, and then asked for three volunteers. The volunteers had to turn in their essays a week ahead of time so the professor and students could rip the victims' works to shreds like hyenas on a carcass on the Serengeti. He asked who would like to volunteer, and I heard a snicker from behind me that sounded like a “Yeah, right.” I, being one who usually enjoys writing, raised my hand. He found his chosen three and proceeded to tell us more details. Again from behind, farther back this time, I heard someone say, “Suckers.” I laughed a little to myself; this would be cake.4

I had work after class, and I set my computer up in the lifeguard office and began to write. But then I had a revelation: the topic I had chosen wasn't something I wanted to share with the entire class. I scrambled over to my bag and pulled out my notes. I looked through them for something a bit more appropriate. I decided that I would choose the most informational topic; my coworkers would be a good subject.5

I typed up the rough draft and looked over it, then realized I had made a huge mistake. Sure, it was chock full of information and witty little lines like “Incompetence runs twelve feet deep at my pool,” but I couldn't find a valid reason for why it changed my views on anything, and there was no way I could translate it to a narrative voice. To top it off, I didn't even stay true to my purpose.6

Once again, I returned to my notes. I started several other drafts. One about my father and how his alcoholism and smoking addiction have influenced me: too serious. Another about my mom: too inappropriate. Even another one about my coworkers at a different job, but I decided not to do that one for legal reasons. I went back to the drawing board and decided to have one last go at the incompetence essay, but to no avail. The essay was a failure, and there was no way to revive it unless, of course, I took one of the topics I mentioned in the essay and expanded on it. No, it would have to be done without.7

I sat down and stared at a new blank screen. I couldn't distract myself with the Internet at work as there was no wireless connection, so this was the perfect environment to generate ideas. Smoke poured from my ears. My cold disabled me from using my brain, and it couldn't have picked a better time. I sipped on my cappuccino, tapped my pen on the desk, and lay my head down in defeat. Suddenly, an idea hit me in the back of the head like a stray water polo ball.8

My fingers danced across the keyboard, and the beginnings of a more successful essay were born. The children rejoiced and paraded through the streets, or at least in my mind they did, for my work was finished. I sat back, laced my fingers on the back of my head, and admired my finished product. Then I remembered I still had to edit it.9

Author notes

The underlines show the only error he found. It like he was going "This is too good. There has to be at least something wrong!"

Out of all the papers, mine was the only one with no marks on the front. This is the final draft. I got a 96 on it, the highest grade in the class

He said it didn't follow the assignment, but I don't see how. I was supposed to write about something I overcame, so I wrote about overcoming my essay. He liked the creativity and everything, it just wasn't "what he was looking for." But he didn't tell me to write a new one, because it was the first.

When I asked a fellow student if she thought it followed the assignment, she said, "I think he just didn't expect that with the three that volunteered on the first essay, he'd find someone who could write as good as you."

I'm really full of myself right now with this. I'm proud of it; sue me

In a list

Please tell me what you think

    : , Your review:

    Comment Suggestion: What is your your first impression?
    : Cost: 0 free left 0 points, You have 0. (?) (Line numbers)
    Ratings:

Comments

1 - 20 of 20

  • Mephitic ID Synergy
    April 8, 2008

    Edit | Reply
    This is better than a good deal of students essays, if only because it isn't utterly banal and self-absorbed superficial tripe. It was relatively good. You might have mentioned the topic of the essay, being incompetence, nearer the beginning, so that the reader could see how that comes about. I would have marked a couple things, as well. I think if you look in "Elements of Style" you will find that the way you used colons was not grammatically acceptable, as in sentence 2 of paragraph 5, where I think that colon should more properly be a semicolon or a period. Another thing I might mark, though this would depend on your audience, are phrases like "chock full of information," and "To top it off," as for a more learned audience they might well seem silly and out of place. Similarly, the use of simile in a couple of places might be inappropriate for such an audience. It's the rudest literary device, I think. "For" is probably an unnecessary preposition here: "find a valid reason for why it changed my views". In paragraph 7, I think that you need a comma before "unless" as that is the conjunction that begins a second, related independent clause. You can take the commas out from around "of course," as it is grammatically acceptable to do so with such short interjections. I'm not sure, also, that the "it" in the last sentence of that paragraph has a clear referent.

    Score 1 for the grammar nazi!

    Hey, not bad at any rate. I like personal essays best as topics when I must write an essay. What kind of class is this? English Composition? Those are highly worthwhile classes.

    Mike


    • GuitarShank silver member
      April 8, 2008
      Edit | Reply
      Yeah, it's Composition 1.

      You know I gotta try to defend some of these

      The colon I think is okay because if it were separated with a period or semicolon, it would've been a bit segmented, making it look like two different thoughts. 'I had a revelation. The topic wasn't...' just makes me think "Now what the hell was the revelation?" lol I dunno. Maybe that's just me.

      The similes were done more in humor than anything else But it's okay 'cause he liked them. Not only that, but he kept quoting my essay when we were about to start the description essay.

      Also, one thing he taught us was this: if you're thinking of putting something down, and a red flag goes up in your head saying to not write it, just put it in.

      I see what you mean in paragraph 7, but the teacher made that mark. I questioned it too, but I went with it. He doesn't really look at grammar with me though, but rather he looks a lot at my style (he's told me he grades me on a different level...)

      And the 'it' refers to the essay. I'm not sure what else I'd remember I had to edit lol

      One more. I'm not sure what you meant by mentioning the essay was incompetence... this one wasn't the incompetence essay; the one about my coworkers was.

      Thanks for the review


      • Mephitic ID Synergy
        April 8, 2008
        Edit | Reply
        Ah, are you learning the different methods of organization, and doing the different types of essays (argumentative, descriptive, etc)? That is all quite helpful.


        • GuitarShank silver member
          April 8, 2008
          Edit | Reply
          I have to write a book analysis today... in class...

          Yeah. First was Narrative, then Descriptive, book report, Persuasive, and he's leaving us in the dark with the last one


          • Mephitic ID Synergy
            April 8, 2008
            Edit | Reply
            Book... report? What is he trying to do to you guys? You mean, like a summary? Or was that an analysis?

            And, what book?


  • Viola.King
    March 6, 2008
    Edit | Reply
    This is pretty damn great. Congrats on the 96.


  • Naive.
    February 14, 2008
    Edit | Reply

    Heh.

    Well, I missed the essay. :[ Sounds like it was pretty good...Just my luck... :]

    -jj

    • GuitarShank silver member
      February 28, 2008
      Edit | Reply
      I put the essay back up if you want to read it. 550 words, so it's not long


      • Naive.
        February 28, 2008

        Edit | Reply
        YAY. Hehe, I'm so glad you put this essay back up. I loved it. I think we've all had times where we've had writer's block while trying to write an essay. I found myself chuckling and smiling as I read, and it's pretty awesome that you only had those two small mistakes. A 96%, you say? Great job, great job. Thanks for putting this back up; it was a great read. Mucho gracias. :]

        -jj


        • GuitarShank silver member
          February 28, 2008
          Edit | Reply
          Technically, it was only one error It was just a repetition of phrases. It's one of the more advanced style errors, which is why I said it looks like he was trying really hard to find something lol


          • Naive.
            February 28, 2008
            Edit | Reply
            He was obviously jealous of your amazing writing essays on essays skills. And such.

            -jj


  • IrishYndina Greeters member
    February 14, 2008

    Edit | Reply
    An essay on overcoming writer's block through the process of writing an essay? *laughs* That's AWESOME! The progressions is great - I like the way it starts with your impatience before moving to the premise, then ends with the solution. Nicely laid out. I find it's usually very entertaining to write about the way you write...

    Ok ok...I'll keep my editorial eye to myself... *sighs*


    • GuitarShank silver member
      February 14, 2008
      Edit | Reply
      Like I said, the class and the teacher are going to proofread it

      It's due today, gotta go in and make me changes


      • IrishYndina Greeters member
        February 28, 2008
        Edit | Reply
        Congrats on the grade! I think he was nit-picking because essayists don't expect essays to be creative, and sometimes can't deal with it if they are...


        • GuitarShank silver member
          February 28, 2008
          Edit | Reply
          Au contraire, he's no essayist

          He's a published author. His book comes out March 21, called The Hanging Woods. I think I want to buy it, just to see what kind of skill I'm learning under.

          And he wishes he were a creative writing teacher, because he loved this piece despite it not being what he was looking for, but he has no time for more than two classes with the book coming out.

          *sigh* how I wish too be that busy. At least his reason for business is worth it


  • SimplyTaylor
    February 13, 2008

    Edit | Reply
    This changed how I think about my own struggle to pin down an idea.

    I'm not alone!


  • ice wolf Greeters member
    February 13, 2008

    Edit | Reply
    This is hilarious Shank. I think you should expand on this and turn it into a story. I told you you were a good writer. I love the style and flare you put into writing an essay. ♥ which is my way of giving kudos


  • Blazing Writer
    February 13, 2008

    Edit | Reply
    O.o Lol What was the essay about? Wait, was the essay about having a hard time to write an essay? Or an essay on how your write your essay? Idk lol your last line is "Then I remembered I still had to edit it." and in your Author Notes it states Do not edit this. Hmm I wonder lol. Well anyway, this is good. Is shows the basic struggle of someone writing an essay and I am sure everyone goes through this. I know I do. Keep up the fantastic job!

    ~Blazing Mike~

    beginning: 5, language: 5, plot: 5, ending: 5, dialog: 5, characters: 5.


    • GuitarShank silver member
      February 13, 2008
      Edit | Reply
      Oh, and I said not to edit it because it's classwork, and I'm only posting it here 'cause I'm proud of it

      If I get revision here, it just seems like cheating lol


    • GuitarShank silver member
      February 13, 2008
      Edit | Reply
      It was supposed to be a narrative essay on either something we overcame or something that changed the way we feel, act, or think

1 - 20 of 20