SW Oscars 2008 - Best Critic

The Storywrite Oscars 2008 are finally on the road. It has been a fun ride so far, with brilliant nominations and now it comes down to talent and talent alone.


The nominees for Best Critic 2008 are:




Bitter Irony
http://storywrite.com/Bitter_Irony


IrishYndina
http://storywrite.com/IrishYndina


Gary Alexander
http://storywrite.com/gary+alexander


gerifitzsimmons
www.storywrite.com/gerifitzsimmons


AuburnSheWolf
http://storywrite.com/AuburnSheWolf







NOTE TO NOMINEES:


Enter a story with your username.
In the body heading please add a link to the page showing all of your comments - you should find the link to this page on the left side bar of your homepage.

Rest assured the judges will respect your privacy and base their decisions on critical comments on stories and poems ONLY.



--Asfand

Contest is Over

  • Contest was judged on September 6, 2008
  • Rewards: Gold: 300, Silver: 75, Bronze: 25, Honorable mention: 2 people
  • Final notes:
    At long last the results are in. It's been a neck to neck competition of the best SW has to offer and I must say, a hearty congrats to everyone!

    Finally, the winner is:


    BITTER IRONY

    Followed by:


    Gary Alexander
    IrishYndina
    AuburnSheWolf &
    Gerifitzsimmons





    To everyone else, congrats and keep writing! Your prowess will surely take you futhur in your lives!

    Good luck in all future endaevours!

Contest Winners

  1. Bitter Irony
    http://storywrite.com/comment/by/Bitter%20Irony
    by Bitter Irony <100 words, on Aug 11 2:10 PM 2008
    Gold trophy winner
    • Viewed by judge. [remove]
  2. For "Best Critic" award...Oscars Contest: Gary Alexander
    I have some 1043 comments credited. The link to these is found NOT on profile page but on accounts page. It is:1
    by Gary Alexander <100 words, 2 comments, on Aug 11 9:06 AM 2008
    Silver trophy winner
    • Commented on by judge. [remove]
  3. IrishYndina
    No story here - for a contest
    by IrishYndina <100 words, on Aug 8 7:24 AM 2008
    Bronze trophy winner
    • Viewed by judge. [remove]
  4. AuburnSheWolf (not a story)
    http://storywrite.com/comment/by/AuburnSheWolf1
    by Ghost of a Siren <100 words, 2 comments, on Aug 11 4:59 AM 2008. In Contest
    Honorable mention
    • Commented on by judge. [remove]

Entries [4]

Add a comment

    : Comment:

Comments

1 - 5 of 5

  • Gary Alexander silver member
    August 3, 2008
    Edit | Reply

    And I'd like to thank...

    whoever put me up for best critic! But, I'd also like to say...there're probably a few people out there in the wings who would put me up for WORST critic as well...if there was such a category!
    Still...I won't look a gift nomination past the feedbag! Thank you.
    GA


  • Token Massacre silver member
    August 3, 2008
    Edit | Reply
    good choices. good luck to all the entrants!


  • IrishYndina Greeters member
    August 5, 2008
    Edit | Reply
    An unexpected nomination - but thank you! I'm glad that someone at least found my comments helpful rather than the ramblings of a punctuation Nazi.


  • Ghost of a Siren
    August 11, 2008
    Edit | Reply
    I'm surprised I got nominated, but thank you!


  • Solidarity silver member
    August 11, 2008
    Edit | Reply
    Looks like a worthy contest - critiquing is so often overlooked.

1 - 5 of 5